In nine seasons with the Yankees, O'Neill hit .303 with a .377 On-base percentage, 1,426 hits, 185 home runs and 858 RBI. He was also a member of four World Series-winning teams.
A fourth-round draft pick by the Reds in 1981 from Columbus Brookhaven High School, O'Neill spent eight seasons in Cincinnati. He hit .259 with a .336 OBP, 679 hits, 96 homers and 411 RBI. He was the right fielder on the 1990 World Series championship team.